Stories/ 子不语/ Poor Ghosts and Rich Ghosts

Poor Ghosts and Rich Ghosts

穷鬼祟人富鬼不崇人

SourceZibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss)
AuthorYuan Mei
EraQing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798
Writtenc. 1788
GhostUnderworldJustice
A thousand old coffins heaped like a mountain behind a convent while plump well-dressed ghosts hover above and ragged ghosts hang back
Illustration generated by AI, based on the ancient Chinese text.

Behind the back gate of the Desheng Convent at West Lake more than a thousand coffins were stored, heaped up like a mountain.

I went to stay there and asked the monks: “Has anything ever been haunted here?”

They said: “These are all rich ghosts. It is peaceful all the year round.”

I said: “In the city, how could there be so many rich people? How could there be so many rich ghosts? And after being kept so long unburied, they are plainly not rich.”

The monk said: “What we call rich is not their condition in life. Any ghost that after death has food and wine offered to it and paper money burned for it we call a rich ghost. These thousand-odd coffins, though they have been kept long unburied, have four seasonal offerings from the monks every year, an Ullambana assembly, and ten million in paper money burned, and the ghosts are all drunk and full, so no wicked thought arises in them.

“Have you not seen that in the world the robbery and fraud are all born of cold and hunger? Among the things sick people say and see, are there any ghosts in fine clothes and handsome with fat faces? Those who haunt and demand offerings are for the most part ghosts with matted hair and bad teeth, ragged and penniless.”

I thought his view very sound, and lived there over a month, and though I had menservants and maids, on the cloudy nights none of them ever heard a ghost cry.

Original classical Chinese text · 原文

所谓富者,非指其生前而言也,凡死后有酒食祭祀、纸钱烧化者,便谓之富鬼。……凡病人口中所说,目中所见,可有衣冠华美、相貌丰腴之鬼乎?凡作祟求祭者,大率皆蓬头历齿,蓝缕穷酸之鬼耳。

From 《穷鬼祟人富鬼不崇人》, Zibuyu juan 22. The whole piece is Yuan Mei's own conversation with a monk, and he endorses the monk's view.

Source. From Zibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss) (子不语), by Yuan Mei , c. 1788. The original text is in the public domain; this English rendering and the accompanying notes are original work.

Keep Reading

Related Stories

Qing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1788 · 子不语

The Magistrate Who Went Down the Well

酆都知县

A county magistrate abolishes the annual tax that his people pay to Hell. The town tells him to explain himself to the gods. So he has himself lowered down a well — and meets Bao Zheng, and Guan Yu, and makes one fatal mistake.

UnderworldJusticeDeity
Qing dynasty · Qianlong–Jiaqing era · 续子不语

The Ghost Who Seized Surplus

掠剩鬼

A dead merchant buys his old friend lunch and explains his new appointment: he has been assigned to seize the surplus. Then he gives him a bouquet that is very heavy.

GhostTricksterUnderworld
Qing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798 · 子不语

The Five One-Eyes

一目五先生

Five ghosts travel together in plague years. Four of them are completely blind. The one with an eye decides who is eaten, and his method of choosing is the most cynical moral arithmetic in the collection.

GhostMonster