Stories/ 子不语/ Intercession in the Underworld

Intercession in the Underworld

赵文华在阴司说情

SourceZibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss)
AuthorYuan Mei
EraQing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798
Writtenc. 1788
JusticeUnderworldSatireOfficialdomGhost
An underworld tribunal hall with a crowned judge rising to greet an arriving official, two chained figures kneeling outside the great gate, a tall pillar with a hanging couplet board, lanterns and dark cloud
Illustration generated by AI, based on the ancient Chinese text.

Zhao Jing of Hangzhou came of a family originally from Cixi. He had a younger brother of a rigid and severe disposition. After the brother married, there was a clever maid in his wife’s family to whom he had never once shown a pleasant face. Jing had his way with her in secret; his brother’s wife knew nothing of it.

Before long the maid was pregnant. The wife’s father suspected his son-in-law. The maid too put up a false story against him, and the husband could not clear himself; and in his mortification he hanged himself.

Two years later, at Jing’s father’s birthday, with guests and friends assembled for the feast, Jing and the maid suddenly fell to the ground and began to babble, and did not come to themselves until the night had passed.

What they said was this:

“We were seized and taken to the courts of the dead, and chained outside the great gate. Presently we heard the drums beat and the court go into session; the ghost runners took us by the hair and flung us down at the foot of the steps, and there was one in a crown with hanging beads seated above, and our brother was brought up to give evidence against us.

“Jing and the maid both submitted to the charge. We did not dare argue. The judgement was about to be settled when suddenly the word came: the Minister Zhao has arrived. On the red card was written your kinsman of the same year, Zhao Wenhua, bows his head.

“The officer of the dead straightened his cap and gown and went out to receive him, giving orders as he went: take the prisoners back and chain them where they were.

“I looked up and saw a couplet on one of the pillars:

Man and ghost are but one barrier, and not one joint of it leaks; yin and yang have no two principles, and from reason and number there is no escape.

It was signed: written by Tao Wangling of Kuaiji.

“I was still staring at it when the word came: the Minister is leaving. The officer called Jing and the maid and gave judgement.

“This case should be judged under the statute on causing death through adultery, reduced by three degrees. In view of the Minister’s speaking for you, you are provisionally returned to the light. And besides — the man was a grown male. What was there about an affair with a serving-maid that he could not simply have admitted, that he must go and take his own life? It is thoroughly contemptible. You are therefore spared, and sent back to the world of the living.”

Nobody in the family could think why Zhao Wenhua should have shielded Jing.

One day they asked the elders of the clan about it, and learned that Wenhua was their ancestor in the seventh generation. He had curried favour with the chief minister Yan, and his descendants were ashamed of him, so the name was never spoken — and nobody had known.

Original classical Chinese text · 原文

杭人赵京,祖籍慈溪。有弟某,性方严。婚后,妇家婢颇慧,未尝假以颜色,京私与狎,弟妻不知。无何,婢孕,妇翁疑婿,婢亦驾词诬婿,婿不能自明,恚投环死。 越二年,京父寿辰,宾朋宴集,京与婢忽仆地呓语,经宿始苏,云:「摄至冥府,与婢械系大门外。俄闻发鼓升堂,鬼役捽其首掷阶下,有冕旒者上坐,引弟质讯。京与婢皆伏罪,不敢置辩。将定谳矣,忽报:『赵尚书至。』红柬上书『年家眷弟赵文华顿首拜。』冥官肃衣冠出迎,命:『带人犯械系故处。』举头见柱上一联云:『人鬼只一关,关节一丝不漏;阴阳无二理,理数二字难逃。』后署『会稽陶望龄题』。正熟视间,报:『赵尚书出矣。』冥官唤京与婢谕云:『本案应照因奸致死罪减三等判,以赵尚书说情,姑放回阳。且赵某身为男子,通婢事有何承认不起?而竟至轻生,亦殊可鄙。故且宽汝,放回阳间。』」举家不知赵文华何故庇京。一日,询诸宗老,始知文华其七世祖也,因谄严相,子孙丑之,故皆讳言,无知者。

From 《趙文華在陰司說情》, Zibuyu juan 10. Translated in full. Zhao Wenhua (d. 1557) was the historical ally of the chief minister Yan Song; 關節 means a joint — and, in examination slang, a pull.

Source. From Zibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss) (子不语), by Yuan Mei , c. 1788. The original text is in the public domain; this English rendering and the accompanying notes are original work.
Where this fits in the universe: The Courts of the Dead

Keep Reading

Related Stories

Qing dynasty · late 17th century · 聊斋志异

Xi Fangping Sues the Underworld

席方平

A son follows his murdered father into the Courts of the Dead and files a lawsuit — through every clerk, every magistrate, every torture the underworld can devise, up to the highest god there is.

UnderworldJusticeGhost
Qing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798 · 子不语

The Case of the Bound Feet

裹足作俑之报

A virtuous Hangzhou scholar is invited down to the underworld to take over from Yang Jisheng, who is being promoted. Before he can decline there is a case on the desk: the last emperor of the Southern Tang, who once bound a dancer's feet into the shape of a new moon. Several hundred thousand footless women have assembled at the Gate of Heaven demanding justice.

JusticeUnderworldSatire
Qing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798 · 子不语

The True Judge Bao and the False

真龙图变假龙图

A magistrate who models himself on Bao Zheng finds a rotting corpse in a well and tortures a confession out of an adulterous couple, to public acclaim. A year later the husband walks back into town from Sichuan and stops to watch the opera they are performing about his own murder.

JusticeSatireOfficialdom